Book Review – American Gods

March 31, 2017 Reviews 6 ★★★

Book Review – American GodsAmerican Gods by Neil Gaiman
Publisher: Headline
Date Published: 2005
Genres: Fantasy, Fiction
Format: eBook
Pages: 640
Audiobook Length: 19 hours 39 minutes
Audiobook Narrator: Daniel Oreskes, Dennis Boutsikaris, Ron McLarty, Sarah Jones
Rating: three-stars
Description: The extraordinary, highly acclaimed epic novel from storytelling genius Neil Gaiman. After three years in prison, Shadow has done his time. But as the time until his release ticks away, he can feel a storm brewing. Two days before he gets out, his wife Laura dies in a mysterious car crash, in adulterous circumstances. Dazed, Shadow travels home, only to encounter the bizarre Mr Wednesday claiming to be a refugee from a distant war, a former god and the king of America. Together they embark on a very strange journey across the States, along the way solving the murders which have occurred every winter in one small American town. But the storm is about to break... Disturbing, gripping and profoundly strange, Gaiman's epic novel sees him on the road to the heart of America. Includes extra material exclusive to this Headline Review edition.

Lynnpic Lynn’s Review:

Another ShelfLove book down; but American Gods was quite a slog. I started in January and finally had to switch to the audio to make some progress. I’m not really sure what the problem was. I usually like Neil Gaiman’s books. But I just didn’t connect with this one.

Let’s go with a list style review.

Things I liked:

  • The beginning of the novel has Shadow and Mr. Wednesday attending a meeting at House on the Rock. They even take a twirl on the carousel. Every time I’ve visited, I wanted to ride the carousel. Though maybe without all the dust and creepy dolls. As a Midwesterner by birth, House on the Rock is iconic. Who hasn’t seen the countless billboards driving through Wisconsin?  These scenes were so well crafted I actually felt like I was there alongside Shadow, wondering what the heck was going on, meeting the other gods, spinning out of control.
  • Post Script and interview with Neil Gaiman: I would have been content with more of the post script and less of the novel. The post script explains the inspiration behind American Gods. Learning of Gaiman’s thoughts behind the immigrant experience and American myths was fascinating. I really feel like the post script ties the whole book together.
  • The concept\premise: Intellectually, I thought the idea of a battle between old gods (Odin, Easter, et al.) and new gods (Media, Mr.World et al.) very intriguing. The notion that roadside attractions are major points of spiritual interest and power is also interesting. Why else would people trek to see the world’s largest ball of yarn?

“This is a bad land for gods” … “You’ve probably all learned that, in your own way. The old gods are ignored. The new gods are as quickly taken up as they are abandoned, cast aside for the next big thing.”

  • The audio narration: It was a full cast recording and I’m always a fan of those. Neil Gaiman even narrates a few sections. Definitely a plus.

Things I didn’t like:

  • Everything in the middle. The plot felt very rambling. The three main plots are: 1) follow Shadow to a Midwestern town, where we learn that teenagers have been disappearing since the beginning of the town; 2) follow Shadow to Southern Illinois where he spends some time at a mortuary; and 3) follow Shadow as he drives Wednesday around to visit other gods to convince them to join the cause. There are a number of other sub-plots. And honestly, I did not care about any of the different story-lines.
  • I didn’t connect with any of the characters. I wouldn’t want to hang out with any of them. And I didn’t care what happened to any of them.

In the battle of old gods vs new, it was me who lost the 20+ hours it took for me to slog through American Gods.  We’ll call this a case of it’s not the book, it’s me.

I would like to point out that I am still excited for the upcoming American Gods tv series. I’m hoping the plot will move along more quickly in one hour segments. If you are interested, check out the trailer below!

Note: Some posts may contain affiliate links. Should you choose to purchase a product, we will receive a small commission for the sale at no additional cost to you. Chapter Break is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to

Rating Report
Overall: 3.1

Subscribe to Chapter Break posts.

Never miss a post on Chapter Break. Subscribe today for all the bookish awesome in your inbox.

Join 17,595 other subscribers

6 Responses to “Book Review – American Gods”

    • Lynn

      The series intrigues me as well, Nicole! And I’m going to guess you won’t need to read the book to follow along!

  1. Rebecca

    I have to reread this. I read it so long ago but it wasn’t my favorite Gaiman – although it was my husband’s favorite. I think I read it at the wrong time, too. I was pregnant, and I didn’t really enjoy anything I read at the time. 🙂
    Rebecca @ The Portsmouth Review
    Follow me on Bloglovin’

  2. Kristine Hall

    It’s been a while since I read American Gods, but I do remember that I really liked it. I can still remember vividly the House on the Rock scene! I thought the premise was amazing. The various gods, mostly left behind but some alive and well among us, really kept me reading. I have watched the promos/trailers for the series, and they all look so bloody! Did I just block those parts out? I remember there was violence, but maybe my imagination tones down the bloody! I am with you, though — didn’t particularly connect with anyone. Enjoyed the voyeuristic view, though! Thanks for sharing your thoughts. I was just suggesting my husband read it, but I will tell him about your sticking points. (Side note: ANYTHING Gaiman narrates is awesome. Listen to him read Trigger Warning if you haven’t. EXCELLENT.)
    Kristine Hall recently posted…Thirteen Therapists

    • Lynn

      There were some bloody scenes, for sure, Kristine – especially towards the end. And thanks for the advice on Trigger Warning. I was thinking about checking out Norse Mythology as well.

Leave a Reply

CommentLuv badge